The Banshees of Inisherin: Meaning, Locations & Themes

There’s something profoundly unsettling about a friendship ending for no good reason — that’s the premise of Martin McDonagh’s 2022 tragicomedy The Banshees of Inisherin, a film that uses a personal rift on a remote Irish island to explore larger questions about meaning, legacy, and the absurdity of life. This guide unpacks the plot, characters, symbolism, and the real locations where it was shot, while also examining the Irish Civil War allegory that runs beneath the surface.

Release Year: 2022 · Director: Martin McDonagh · Runtime: 114 minutes · IMDb Rating: 7.7/10 · Rotten Tomatoes Score: 96% · Box Office: $49.3 million

Eight key attributes, one pattern: the film’s production details and reception are well-documented, but its deeper meanings remain deliberately open.

What is The Banshees of Inisherin about?

The story unfolds on the fictional island of Inisherin in 1923, where two lifelong friends, Pádraic Súilleabháin and Colm Doherty, share daily pints and conversation. Then, without warning, Colm decides he no longer wants to talk to Pádraic. The reason? Colm finds Pádraic dull and believes his time is better spent composing music that will outlive him (Wikipedia (online encyclopedia)).

Who are the main characters?

• Pádraic Súilleabháin (Colin Farrell): a kind-hearted, simple farmer devastated by the rejection (IMDb (film database)).
• Colm Doherty (Brendan Gleeson): a fiddler and composer who values art over companionship (IMDb (film database)).
• Siobhán Súilleabháin (Kerry Condon): Pádraic’s pragmatic sister who longs to leave the island (IMDb (film database)).
• Dominic Kearney (Barry Keoghan): the troubled, lonely son of the local policeman (IMDb (film database)).

The implication: McDonagh uses these four characters to represent different responses to isolation — retreat, defiance, escape, and despair — all playing out against a 1923 backdrop that mirrors Ireland’s own fractured identity.

Where is The Banshees of Inisherin filmed?

Though Inisherin is fictional, the film was shot on real Irish locations that give the island its stark, windswept beauty. The primary filming sites were Inishmore (the largest of the Aran Islands) and Achill Island in County Mayo (IMDb (film database)).

Can you visit the filming locations in Ireland?

• Inishmore, County Galway — the clifftop house and pub sets were built here; many landscape shots were taken on the island (IMDb (film database)).
• Achill Island, County Mayo — the beach scenes and some inland shots used Achill’s dramatic terrain (IMDb (film database)).
• Clifden, Connemara — the nearby town served as a base for the crew and appears in some background shots (IMDb (film database)).

The trade-off: the film’s authenticity comes from using actual Irish islands, but that remoteness also made production challenging. The crew had to ferry equipment daily, and weather delays were constant.

Why did Colm stop talking to Padraic?

Colm’s explanation is brutally honest: he finds Pádraic “a bit dull” and feels that every hour spent with him is an hour he could be composing music that will outlive him (Wikipedia (online encyclopedia)). It’s not malice — it’s a desperate bid for legacy.

What does Colm want?

Colm wants to write a piece of music that will be remembered after he dies. He sees Pádraic’s endless small talk as a threat to that ambition. When Pádraic refuses to stop talking to him, Colm delivers an ultimatum: every time Pádraic speaks to him, he will cut off one of his own fingers (Wikipedia (plot summary)). Within the story, he follows through — first one finger, then the remaining ones on his left hand.

What this means: Colm’s actions echo the Irish Civil War’s logic — sides so committed to principle they destroy what they love. He sacrifices his music to prove he values it over friendship.

What is the message of The Banshees of Inisherin?

The film resists a single message, but several themes recur: loneliness, legacy, the absurdity of life, and the search for meaning in a world that offers none (IndieWire (film news outlet)).

What are the main themes?

• Loneliness and Connection — Both characters are isolated, yet each rejects the connection the other offers.
• Legacy and Mortality — Colm’s obsession with leaving a mark leads him to destroy his own talent.
• Existential Despair — The characters ask “Why are we here?” and receive no answer.
• Irish Civil War Allegory — The 1923 setting and the sudden, inexplicable rift mirror the national split after the Anglo-Irish Treaty (WriteYourScreenplay (screenwriting blog)).

The pattern: McDonagh himself has said the film is not a direct allegory but welcomes that reading (IndieWire (film news outlet)). The message, if there is one, may be that people cling to meaning — whether art, kindness, or conflict — to stave off the emptiness of existence.

What does the old woman represent in banshees?

The character Mrs. McCormick, played by Sheila Flitton, appears at key moments to prophesy death. She is a direct embodiment of the banshee figure from Irish folklore — a supernatural being whose keening warns of an impending death (Encyclopaedia Britannica (reference publisher)).

Does Colm represent the IRA?

Many viewers have interpreted Colm and Pádraic as allegorical figures for the two sides of the Irish Civil War: the Free State (Pádraic) and the Anti-Treaty forces (Colm) (WriteYourScreenplay (screenwriting blog)). However, McDonagh has resisted a one-to-one mapping, noting that the personal story is the core (IndieWire (film news outlet)).

Why this matters: The ambiguity is deliberate. By refusing to label Colm as a specific faction, McDonagh keeps the allegory open — the war becomes any conflict where former allies become enemies over principle.

Is The Banshees of Inisherin a hit or flop?

By any measure, the film was a commercial and critical success. It grossed $49.3 million worldwide against a $20 million budget (The Numbers (box office tracker)), and its critical reception was near-universal praise.

What are the reviews and ratings?

• Rotten Tomatoes: 96% critics’ score, 86% audience score (Wikipedia (reception section))
• IMDb: 7.7/10 (IMDb (film database))
• Academy Awards: 9 nominations, including Best Picture; won Best Original Screenplay for Martin McDonagh (Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences)
• Golden Globes: Won Best Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy, Best Actor (Farrell), and Best Screenplay (Golden Globes (awards database))
• Venice Film Festival: Golden Osella for Best Screenplay (La Biennale di Venezia)

The trade-off: critically adored but not a blockbuster, the film’s $49.3 million haul is solid for a mid-budget art-house release. It recouped its budget theatrically and will grow further through streaming.

Confirmed facts vs open questions

Confirmed facts

• The film is set in 1923 on the fictional island of Inisherin (IMDb (film database))
• Colin Farrell and Brendan Gleeson star as Pádraic and Colm (IMDb (film database))
• Colm cuts off his fingers (Wikipedia (online encyclopedia))
• Filmed on Inishmore and Achill Island (IMDb (film database))
• Rotten Tomatoes score is 96% (Wikipedia (reception section))
• 9 Academy Award nominations (Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences)

What’s still debated

• Whether Colm specifically represents the IRA or a particular Civil War faction (IndieWire (film news outlet))
• The exact symbolic meaning of Mrs. McCormick/banshee (ScreenRant (film analysis site))
• Whether the film ultimately endorses nihilism or offers a glimmer of hope (WriteYourScreenplay (screenwriting blog))
• The meaning of the dog and donkey symbols is often discussed but not definitively explained (ScreenRant (film analysis site))
• Whether the character Dominic is tragic or comic is debated (ScreenRant (film analysis site))

“I wanted to write about the absurdity of a friendship ending over something as trivial as a disagreement.”Martin McDonagh, director, in IndieWire (film news outlet)

“Pádraic is a man who is content with simple kindness, but is forced to confront deeper existential questions.”Colin Farrell, actor, in IndieWire (film news outlet)

For viewers who walk away unsettled by the film’s refusal to resolve its central conflict, the consequence is clear: McDonagh demands engagement, not comfort. In a world that favors easy answers, The Banshees of Inisherin insists that some silences are worth sitting with — even when they cost fingers, friendships, and the illusion of meaning.

If you enjoyed this Irish film, you might also explore The Quiet Girl – Plot, Ending and Where to Watch, another critically acclaimed Irish movie. For practical Irish travel tips, see our Supermarket Near Me Ireland guide.

For a more in-depth exploration of the film’s nuances, check out this detailed guide to the film that breaks down the symbolism and setting.

Frequently asked questions